Jo was a returning college student in their 30s. After years in the workforce, they enrolled in a psychology course to better understand their own experiences with anxiety and depression. One evening, during a class discussion on ethics in therapy, Jo shared a story about their cousin Amina.
Amina, 28, had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. After a manic episode that led to risky behavior and a car accident, she was hospitalized involuntarily. Jo remembered the family's distress and Amina's anger. "She kept saying, 'I'm not crazy. You can't lock me up.'"
Professor Lee, a licensed psychologist and ethics researcher, guided the class through the complexities of involuntary treatment. "It's one of the most difficult decisions clinicians face," she explained. "We must balance a person's right to refuse care with the need to protect them, and sometimes others, from harm."
Jo asked, "But what if someone refuses treatment because they don't trust the system? Isn't that their right?"
Professor Lee nodded. "Yes, autonomy is a core value in psychology. But when someone's judgment is impaired by a mental health crisis, the law allows temporary intervention. The goal is stabilization, not punishment."
The class explored real-world cases, including Amina's. They debated whether her hospitalization was justified and what alternatives might have respected her autonomy more. Jo left class that day with a deeper understanding and more questions.
Check out this video to learn more about how bipolar disorder affects mood, thinking, and treatment.
Curious to learn more, Jo read an article on recent legal reforms and ethical debates surrounding involuntary treatment. She found that while most clinicians agree on the importance of autonomy, they also recognize the need for intervention when a person poses a danger to themselves or others.
Some states have adopted assisted outpatient treatment (AOT) programs, which allow individuals to receive care while living in the community, rather than being hospitalized. These programs aim to reduce trauma and improve long-term outcomes.
However, critics argue that even outpatient mandates can feel coercive. The article emphasized the importance of clear communication, patient advocacy, and trauma-informed care in all forms of involuntary treatment.
Six months after her hospitalization, Amina returned to school through a continuing education program. She joined a peer support group and began working with a therapist who specialized in collaborative care.
"I still don't agree with how it happened," she told Jo, "but I understand why they did it. I just wish someone had explained things better."
Jo shared her story in a class presentation, highlighting the importance of empathy, transparency, and ethical decision-making in therapy. Their classmates were moved to think more deeply about the role of psychology in protecting both rights and well-being.
Involuntary treatment raises complex questions about autonomy, safety, and ethics. While the goal is always to help, the methods must be carefully considered. Psychologists, legal professionals, and patients themselves all play a role in shaping compassionate, ethical care.
Answer the following questions to reflect on key ideas from the case study. Remember to print your work before leaving this page!
Smart, B. D., Kalathil, K., McCall, W. V., Munjal, S., Kirkendall, H., Patel, M., Taliaferro, A., Yaegar, L. H., & Iltis, A. S. (2025). "Involuntary" and "voluntary" in psychiatric, behavioral, and mental health services: A scoping review of definitions. Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11414-025-09940-8
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC-BY 4.0).
TED-Ed. (2017, February 9). What is bipolar disorder? - Helen M. Farrell [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/RrWBhVlD1H8?si=1c7ngYnezQVdJrek
PhotoSpirit on Adobe Stock. "Car crash."
loreanto on Adobe Stock. "Psychotherapy session, woman talking to his psychologist."
Monkey Business on Adobe Stock. "Female Tutor Leading Discussion Group Amongst High School Pupils."