Born This Way or Made This Way?


Chapter 11: Personality

Learning Outcomes

  • Describe how personality traits are influenced by genetic and environmental factors
  • Evaluate the role of temperament and life experiences in shaping personality
  • Apply psychological reasoning to real-world questions about personality development

Key Terms

Five Factor Model
theory that personality is composed of five factors or traits, including openness, conscientiousness, extroversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism
heritability
proportion of difference among people that is attributed to genetics
personality
long-standing traits and patterns that propel individuals to consistently think, feel, and behave in specific ways
temperament
innate traits that influence how one thinks, behaves, and reacts with the environment
traits
characteristic ways of behaving

The Personality Puzzle

Bennett, a first-year psychology major, had always been curious about what made people tick. After taking the Big Five personality inventory in class, they were surprised by their results: high in openness and agreeableness but low in extroversion. What puzzled Bennett most was how different their results were from their twin sibling, Taylor, who was outgoing, assertive, and often the center of attention.

Two twins: one posing for the camera, the other hiding behind his hands

"We grew up in the same house, went to the same schools, and had the same parents," Bennett said during a class discussion. "So why are we so different?"

Their professor introduced the concept of behavioral genetics, explaining how twin studies have shown that personality traits are influenced by both genetic factors and environmental influences. Bennett learned that while identical twins share the same DNA, their personalities can still diverge due to differences in experiences, peer groups, and even birth order.

Bennett began reflecting on their own upbringing. Taylor had always been more involved in sports and social clubs, while Bennett preferred books and quiet hobbies. Even though they shared a home, their environments—defined by choices, interactions, and opportunities—had shaped them in unique ways.

The class also discussed temperament, the biologically based tendencies that appear early in life. Bennett remembered being described as a "quiet baby," while Taylor was "always on the move." These early traits, shaped by both nature and nurture, had evolved into distinct personalities.

Two newborn twins

"I used to think personality was fixed," Bennett said. "But maybe it's more like a sketch, where some of the lines are inherited, but the colors come from life."

1. On Your Own

What best describes the concept of heritability? Select the best answer.

Nature Meets Nurture

Research shows that personality is shaped by a dynamic interaction between genetic predispositions and environmental contexts. Twin studies, like those discussed in Bennett's class, reveal that even genetically identical individuals can develop distinct personalities. This is because life experiences—friendships, challenges, opportunities—play a powerful role in shaping how traits are expressed.

The Five Factor Model (sometimes called the Big Five) helps psychologists understand personality across cultures and contexts. Traits like openness, conscientiousness, and extroversion are influenced by both inherited tendencies and life experiences. For example, a person may be genetically inclined toward extroversion but become more introverted due to social anxiety or cultural norms.

Two young adult twins

Understanding personality as both stable and flexible allows students like Bennett to appreciate the complexity of human behavior. It also encourages self-reflection: Which parts of who we are come from our genes, and which parts are shaped by the world around us?

2. On Your Own

Determine whether the following statement is true or false.

Temperament refers to how a person reacts to the world, including their activity level, starting when they are very young.

Bennett's Discovery

Bennett began journaling about their personality traits and how they had changed over time. They noticed that while they had always been quiet, college had helped them become more open to new experiences. They joined a book club, started volunteering, and even gave a presentation in class.

"I'm still me," Bennett said, "but I'm also growing. Maybe personality isn't just who you are but also who you're becoming."

3. On Your Own

What personality traits are included in the Five Factor, or Big Five, Model? Select the three that apply.

Explore the Concept

Check out this video about twin studies and what they can teach researchers about personality, temperament, and more.

Reflect & Respond

Answer the following questions to reflect on key ideas from the case study. Remember to print your work before leaving this page!

  1. How do genetic and environmental factors interact to shape personality?
  2. In what ways can early temperament influence long-term personality traits?
  3. How can understanding personality traits help us in relationships, school, or work?
  4. Reflect on your own personality. Which traits feel inherited, and which feel shaped by experience?
  5. What does Bennett's metaphor of personality as a "sketch" suggest about the flexibility of traits over time?

References

BBC Global. (2022, February 16). What identical twins separated at birth teach us about genetics - BBC REEL [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/JMlJcOSRX-8?si=odCr7xo658VMa8NI

Polderman, T. J. C., Benyamin, B., de Leeuw, C. A., Sullivan, P. F., van Bochoven, A., Visscher, P. M., & Posthuma, D. (2015). Meta-analysis of the heritability of human traits based on fifty years of twin studies. Nature Genetics, 47(7), 702—709. https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.3285
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC-BY 4.0).

Photo Credits

jbrown on Adobe Stock. "Young African American Sister and Brother the Girl is an Obvious Extrovert with Mouth Open and Hands in the Air The Boy is Hiding Behind His Hands Like an Introvert."

Irina on Adobe Stock. "Close-up portrait of newborn twins laying by heads in father's hands. Yawning newborn girl. Cute and tender photo of newborn twin girls. Selective focus. Film grain."

ЮРиЙ ПОЗДНиКОВ on Adobe Stock. "Twin sisters posing together, wearing matching pajamas."